Mill Creek Gardens, rated with a score of 9.5 from 19 reviewers, is one of the most popular hotels in Winamac. Other top stays include German Haus Individual Rental, with an average rating of 9.8 from 11 reviewers, and Riverfront Home with Beautiful Views of Tippecanoe River in Winamac, IN, with a score of 9.7 from 20 reviewers.